Blog

SEO for Coaches: I Reviewed a Real Google Listing, Live

By Martin Drendel • November 18, 2026 • 21 min read

By Martin Drendel, Founder, 741 Studio. Published November 18, 2026. Last checked November 18, 2026.

The video is in German. In it, I review a real coaching business's Google presence live, point by point, the same way I do this for prospects on a regular basis. The business itself stays unnamed in this article. What follows applies to any coach, trainer, consultant or keynote speaker with real clients and real local demand.

Clicking loads the video from YouTube (youtube-nocookie.com).

Short answer

SEO for coaches does not happen automatically, even when the demand is real. In the case reviewed here, Google lists the business under the category that translates to "Doctor," not speaker, coach or trainer. The listing has 0 reviews, and the business's own homepage scores only 13 of 44 points on our first-screen checklist. The result is a listing that convinces neither Google nor real visitors, despite provable demand for exactly this service.

A quick correction first

The public title of this video names a different field than the one actually reviewed in it. The content shows a live review of a business coach and keynote speaker's Google presence, not a business from the field the title suggests. This article follows the real content of the video, not its title. The name and location of the reviewed business stay unnamed here, the same way the video itself never gives a surname. That does not change the numbers themselves. Every number in this article comes from the same real audit, regardless of which title the video runs under.

SEO for coaches starts with the right Google category

Google sorts every listing into a category before a single search happens. In the case reviewed here, that category translates to "Doctor," not speaker, coach or trainer. For SEO for coaches, that is not a small mistake. The category decides which searches a listing can even appear in, and which fields Google lets the business fill in. It also decides which other businesses Google compares the listing against.

A business listed as a doctor gets compared with medical practices, not with other coaches or speakers. That skews what Google treats as relevant before content, reviews or photos ever come into play. The category is the first lever to pull, not the last, and changing it costs nothing. It only changes what is recorded correctly in the first place.

In the video, I show why this stands out in this particular case. The business has six written testimonials from event organizers on its own website, but not a single review on Google. The reason: the listing has never been verified by its owner. Without a verified listing, the category cannot be changed. A phone number and photos cannot be added, and reviews that customers want to leave have nowhere to go.

For comparison, the four competitors who rank ahead of this business for the same local search carry Google categories that translate to "coaching center," "life coach" and "consultant." None of them runs under "Doctor." That is the difference between a listing that was set up once and never touched again, and a listing that matches the actual service. The category can be changed at any time through the verified Google Business Profile. The website and its copy can stay exactly as they are. The underlying work does not need to change at all.

How to check this on your own listing: search your business name on Google or open it in Google Maps, and look at the category shown directly under the name. If it names something that does not match what you actually do, you can change it once the profile is verified. A second check: look at the categories of the competitors who outrank you for your main search term. If none of them matches your category, that is a signal worth acting on.

A Google Business Profile actually carries two kinds of category: one primary category, which Google weighs the most, and up to several secondary categories alongside it. Many coaches never touch either after the first setup. Getting the primary category right matters more than adding a long list of secondary ones, because it is the primary category that decides which comparison set Google places the business into in the first place.

With many coaches, nobody has looked at the category since the listing was first created. That is the real problem. A quick look at the category on file costs only a few minutes and shows immediately whether it still matches the actual service.

None of this requires outside help by itself. A verified owner can open the Google Business Profile, edit the business information and change the primary category in a few clicks. The harder part is usually not the click itself. It is noticing that the category is wrong in the first place, since Google never sends a notice saying a listing has drifted out of its correct category over time.

Our free Google visibility audit checks the category and the reviews, together with the homepage, in one review.

The 49-point grid: 0 of 49 in the top 3

For the review, we ran the Google Maps listing through a systematic grid scan. The grid covers 49 measurement points in a 5-kilometer radius around the city center, using the search term a real prospect would type in when looking for a business coach nearby. At every single one of these 49 points, Google shows its own order of listings, depending on how close the searcher sits to each business.

The result: at none of the 49 points does the reviewed listing appear among the top three results. Not even in the top 20. Anyone searching for a business coach anywhere in that radius will practically never see this listing, no matter how close they sit to the business itself.

The four most visible competitors in the same search area have 1, 1, 26 and 28 reviews. The reviewed listing has 0. Anyone searching for a business coach in this area sees only competitors with at least one review, usually far more, in the map results.

This pattern repeats often with coaches and consultants. The underlying service is real, the Google profile simply does not show it. A grid scan makes that gap visible at every single point, instead of guessing it from one search.

Google states plainly what local results are mainly based on. Its own current wording: "Local results are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity." Relevance is how well a profile matches the search. Distance is how far the business sits from the searcher. The third factor, which Google explains under the heading "Prominence," means how well known a business is, based partly on how many websites link to it and how many reviews it has. Distance is one of three factors, not the only one.

The four most visible competitors sit 0.4 to 2.5 kilometers from the city center. The reviewed business sits 4.2 kilometers away, measured on 2026-11-16. That explains part of the gap, but not all of it. On relevance, the right category matters. On popularity, both reviews and credible links matter. On both factors, the reviewed listing is behind as well.

A single search from one device tells a coach almost nothing reliable about this, because the map results change with the searcher's own location. That is exactly why a grid scan, not a single search, is the right tool: it repeats the same search from 49 separate points so the pattern becomes visible instead of guessed. A business that looks "fine" from its own office can still be close to invisible a few kilometers away, in the direction most of its real demand actually comes from.

This also means that distance alone cannot be fixed the way a category or a review count can. A coach cannot move their office to chase a slightly better position on the grid. What can be controlled is relevance and popularity, which is exactly why those two levers, not location, are where the four steps later in this article start.

We cover this and the other two local ranking factors, with Google's own current wording, in our guide to how Google ranks local results.

A coaching website that stopped in 2023

For most visitors, the homepage is the only place where they decide in seconds whether to stay or leave. We check the first screen of every website against a fixed 44-point checklist. Alongside that, we ask five simple questions that a visitor wants answered within seconds: what is on offer, where is the provider based, why this provider specifically, how do I book an appointment, and who is the person behind it.

In the case reviewed here, four of these five questions went unanswered on the first screen. The offer shown there was an outdated online training, not the actual coaching or speaking services. The location was missing entirely. There was no quote and no number showing why this particular provider is the right choice. And the booking button led, as described above, nowhere at all.

In the case reviewed here, the homepage scores 13 of 44 points. On the first screen, the site still advertises an online training with a signup date from mid-2023 and a button that leads nowhere. That date is roughly three and a half years in the past at the time of reading. Target for a first screen that actually works: 36 or more of 44 points.

The problem is not limited to the homepage. Subpages advertise outdated offers too: one speaking page still names a coaching module from 2020, another page a webinar from the same year. To a visitor, that reads like a website nobody maintains anymore, even though the business itself is active.

The technical basics are thin as well: the site only carries structured data for a Person and a Website, none for a business with its own address. Structured data is the part of a page that is written for Google rather than for a visitor; it states plainly what kind of entity a page belongs to. Without a business entity in that data, Google has to infer far more from the visible text alone, on top of the wrong category already set in the Google Business Profile.

The first-screen checklist and the five-question test both work the same way on mobile as on desktop, and most coaching searches now happen on a phone first. A first screen that scores well on a laptop but hides the offer or the booking button below the fold on a phone still fails the same five questions for most real visitors.

This points to a problem many coaches share. A good coaching website does not need more text. It needs a current offer, a headline that says exactly what for, and a button with an actual destination. The same holds for any website for coaches: without a current first screen, even a professionally strong site stays invisible, and outdated offers on subpages only reinforce that impression.

What a working first screen looks like in practice: a clear photo of the person, a headline that is instantly readable, a specific offer named in plain words, proof that fits the claim, and one button that leads somewhere real. None of that requires a rebuild from scratch. It requires someone to actually look at what is there today, and to update it with the same regularity as the rest of the business, rather than treating a website as something that gets built once and then left alone for years.

Our free Google visibility audit checks this exact first screen too, together with the Google listing and the reviews.

The demand is real, the website is nowhere to be found

The business's own site does not appear in Google's organic top 20 for the local search term that matches its service. Even a search for the business's own name does not return the homepage in the top 10. Only one subpage, the privacy policy, shows up at all, at position 8.

That is the core of SEO for coaches: demand and visibility are two separate things. People searching for a business coach, a keynote speaker or a communication trainer exist whether or not any single website shows up for that search. A business that does not build its pages around the words people actually type stays invisible for that demand, no matter how strong the underlying work is.

The scale of this demand is real and measurable, even without naming this specific business's market. In the United States, "coaching website" alone gets about 5,400 searches a month, and "website for coaches" gets roughly the same (Google Ads data, 12-month average, read 2026-11-18). Most of that traffic goes to website builders and template sellers, not to individual coaches. The narrower, more honest question, "seo for coaches," gets only about 40 searches a month in the same market, but related terms show the same gap between demand and who actually answers it: "coaching marketing" about 170 a month, "business coach marketing" about 70, "life coach marketing" about 50. The volume is smaller than for a generic head term, but every one of these searches is someone actively looking for help with exactly this problem.

A look at the reviewed business's own blog shows how this plays out in practice. 28 of 30 measured blog articles cover a single topic with nearly identical titles. None of these articles names the business's real service or location in the title. To Google, that reads like a website about one narrow subject, not the site of a coach or speaker with real demand behind it. These articles are not short either: they run between 2,755 and 5,621 words each. The topic, not the length, is the problem.

Writing more content is not automatically the fix, and this is where the volume numbers above matter again. A dozen more long articles on the same narrow topic would not change what the site is about in Google's eyes. The site would simply become a bigger, more detailed site about that one thing. Depth helps only once it is depth on the terms that real prospects actually search for, which is a different decision than simply publishing more.

A single keyword also rarely stands alone. A coach who ranks for "business coach" but ignores "keynote speaker" or "communication training" is still leaving real, searchable demand on the table, even after the main keyword is fixed. That is why a content plan built around real search terms usually covers a small cluster of related phrases rather than one single term.

That distinction also explains why paid search and organic SEO solve different problems here. Google Ads can put a listing in front of searchers for "business coach marketing" or "coaching marketing" within days, at the cost shown for each click. Organic visibility for the same terms takes longer to build, through the category fix, the homepage rebuild and real content on the right topics, but it keeps working without a per-click cost once it is in place. Neither replaces the other; a business with a 13-of-44 homepage and a mismatched category would waste a large share of any paid traffic it bought in the meantime, for the same reason it is invisible organically.

Backlink cleanup: 34 of 86 linking domains with a high spam score

Not every link to a domain counts as an advantage. We checked all 86 domains that link to the reviewed business's website, 119 individual backlinks in total. 34 of these 86 domains carry a spam score of 60 or more, roughly 40 percent, including casino and gambling sites.

That skews the picture Google has of the domain. A website with many credible, topic-relevant links looks more trustworthy to Google. A website with many links from casino and gambling sites looks different: like a domain nobody maintains, even if that link profile was never the business's own doing.

What this means for a domain in the same position:

  • Google can read such links as a signal of poor link building, even when the business itself did nothing to cause it.
  • Every new, credible link, for example from a real business directory, offsets this effect over time, but does not cancel out the bad links immediately.
  • The most damaging domains can be reported to Google individually as untrustworthy, instead of left alone.
  • A single cleanup is not enough. New spam links appear on their own, without any action from the business. A regular, repeated check of the same domain list belongs in the routine, not a one-time comparison.

In practice, this works as a short recurring task rather than a one-time project: pull the current list of linking domains, check each one against a spam-score tool, and report the worst offenders as not affiliated with the business. Once a year, or every six months for a site that picks up spam links quickly, is enough for most small businesses. It is not a task that needs to happen daily, but it does need to happen on a schedule, because the list of bad links never stays the same for long.

Clean, local directory listings are the simplest counterweight to spam links. We cover real, credible directories to work through in our guide to the three levers of local SEO.

What follows from this review: four steps, in the right order

The order of these steps is not random. Each one builds on the one before it.

  1. Fix the Google category and verify the listing as the owner. Without a verified listing, nothing else here can change. That covers the phone number and photos as well as new reviews. This usually takes a few days. Once verified, it is worth checking the category again every few months, since a business can drift into the wrong one after a service change without anyone noticing.
  2. Rebuild the first screen of the website around the real search term: name the offer and the location. The button should lead to a booking, not to an outdated training. At the same time, remove outdated offers from subpages before new visitors find them. Check this on a phone screen specifically, not only on a laptop.
  3. Rewrite content around the words customers actually use. "Coach" alone is rarely enough; the real demand often sits with more specific terms like keynote speaker or communication training. A blog that serves only one narrow side topic does little for that. New content works best once it answers a real, specific search, not a general theme the business happens to like writing about.
  4. Clean up spam links and build new, credible ones, for example through real business directories. This takes the longest, but it can start alongside the first three steps. Treat it as a recurring check, not a single cleanup.

Good coaching marketing starts exactly here: fix the foundation that new content is even found on, before writing any new content at all.

If you want to know how your own Google listing and website score today: we follow the same process at 741 that you just read about, in three steps. First, Status-Quo Analysis: we check your listings, your website, and your review profile inside out. Next, Building Visibility: we optimize your Google Business Profile, clean up incorrect company data on the web, and create content that attracts local customers. Last, Reviews & Citations: we help you systematically collect reviews and monitor your rankings in Google Maps so you stay visible for searches like the one this business coach is missing right now, and so you keep attracting qualified organic traffic instead of relying on one-off searches. On the first, free call, we show you specifically which of these steps would move the needle for you first.

Book a free call

It takes 15 minutes and costs nothing. You are not committing to anything.

If you would rather just watch first: our free Google visibility audit delivers the same kind of analysis as a personal video, sent within 2 hours by WhatsApp and email, with no call required.

Frequently asked questions

Do coaches need SEO if they already have real clients?

Yes, because Google visibility does not follow automatically from good work. In the case reviewed here, three things were wrong at once: a mismatched Google category, no reviews, and a homepage that names neither the offer nor the location clearly. Each one of those can be fixed separately from the actual coaching work itself. None of the three needs a brand-new website; all three can be changed on the existing one.

How do I know if my Google Business Profile has the wrong category?

Open your own listing in Google Search or Google Maps and look at the category shown under the name. If it names something unrelated to your actual service, the way "Doctor" did here instead of coach or trainer, you can change it through your verified Google Business Profile. A second signal: check the categories of the competitors who outrank you for your main search. In this case, they ran under "coaching center," "life coach" and "consultant," none under "Doctor."

How much do reviews actually matter for visibility as a coach or consultant on Google?

A great deal. In the case reviewed here, the four most visible competitors had 1, 1, 26 and 28 reviews, and the reviewed listing had 0. Reviews are one of the signals Google uses to order listings in the map results, alongside category and distance, under what Google itself calls "prominence."

What does it mean if many websites link to my site, but with a bad reputation?

Little to nothing, and it can actually hurt. In the case reviewed here, 34 of 86 linking domains had a high spam score, 119 backlinks in total, including casino and gambling sites. The raw number of links says little as long as nobody checks who is actually linking. Such links can be checked individually and reported to Google as untrustworthy, rather than left as they are.

Should I optimize for "coach," or for what my customers actually type into Google?

For what customers actually type. "Coach" alone is often too broad to meet real demand. In the United States, a related, more specific search like "coaching marketing" gets around 170 searches a month, while the broad head term "coaching website" gets around 5,400. Terms like keynote speaker, business coach or communication training are easier to measure and easier to answer with a dedicated page than one broad umbrella term.

Is "SEO for coaches" even worth pursuing if the search volume looks small?

Yes, if you look at the right numbers. The exact phrase "seo for coaches" gets only around 40 searches a month in the United States, but that is the question of someone already looking for this exact kind of help. The real opportunity sits in the much larger volume around it, like "coaching website" at roughly 5,400 searches a month, almost all of which currently goes to website builders and template sellers rather than individual coaches.

How can a small, local business improve Google visibility and attract qualified organic traffic?

By fixing the same three things this review checked, in order: the Google Business Profile category and verification, the homepage's first screen built around real search terms, and the review and backlink profile behind the listing. In the case reviewed here, correcting the category and verifying the listing comes first, because nothing else can change without it. After that, a first screen that names the real offer and location turns search traffic into actual contact, and content built around the terms customers really type, like keynote speaker or communication training rather than "coach" alone, brings in organic traffic that matches real demand instead of a narrow side topic.

Can I fix all of this myself, without rebuilding the whole website?

Yes, in most cases. Correcting a Google category, verifying a listing, rewriting a homepage's first screen, or removing an outdated offer from a subpage do not require a new website. In the case reviewed here, every single finding, the category, the 0 reviews, the 13-of-44 homepage and the spam links, could be fixed on the business's existing site and existing Google listing. A full rebuild is sometimes the right call, but it is a choice, not a requirement, for fixing any of these specific problems.

How long does it take before these fixes show up in search results?

It depends on the fix. Verifying a Google Business Profile and correcting its category are usually confirmed within days. New reviews can start arriving as soon as the profile accepts them. A rebuilt first screen changes the experience the moment it goes live, though it takes longer for Google to fully re-index a changed page and for new content to earn its own ranking. A backlink cleanup and new content both work over a longer horizon, closer to months than days, because they depend on Google recrawling and on new, credible links actually appearing. None of this is instant, which is exactly why the order of the four steps above matters.

About Martin

I am Martin Drendel, founder of 741 Studio, for over ten years in digital marketing for local businesses. I review Google listings like this regularly, usually on request through LinkedIn, and I show exactly what I described in this article: real numbers instead of guesses. No business gets put on the spot in the process. Every one gets the same review and the same list of next steps.

Book a free call

It takes 15 minutes and costs nothing. You are not committing to anything.

Let's talk

Choose how you'd like to start your project with us.

WhatsApp Email Instagram